Product liability · Medical devices
Injured by a defective implant in Queensland?
TGA approval isn’t a defence: a device can be on the register and still have a safety defect. The safety defect claim’s 10-year limit runs from when the maker supplied the device, not from your surgery. (Australian Consumer Law s 143) A negligence claim has a different time limit.
- No-obligation first consultation
- No win, no fee*
- We set out our costs in writing at the start.
Time limits
Several clocks run at once, from different starting points.
Claim facts
-
Notice of claim
Within 9 months of the injury (or of first symptoms, if later), or 1 month after you first ask a lawyer to act for you and the respondent is identified, whichever comes first. (PIPA s 9(3)) A late notice can still be given, with a reasonable excuse for the delay. (s 9(5))
9 months
-
Safety defect claim
Within 3 years of when you knew, or should have known, of the loss, the defect and who the maker is. (Australian Consumer Law s 143) For injury damages, a separate 3-year limit can start earlier, from when you knew, or should have known, of the injury and its cause, so don’t wait to find out who made it. (Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) ss 87F, 87G)
3 years
-
Safety defect cut-off
A safety defect claim must start within 10 years after the maker supplied the product, even if the injury shows up later. (Australian Consumer Law s 143) This cut-off doesn’t apply to a negligence claim.
10 years
-
Negligence claim
Generally within 3 years of the injury. (Limitation of Actions Act 1974 (Qld) s 11)
3 years
Several clocks run at once. The earliest one is usually the notice of claim.
If it happened to a child
Don’t assume you can wait until your child turns 18. Some consumer law deadlines run from when the product was supplied, or from when a parent knew of the injury.
Was it the care, not the device?
If the problem was how the device was chosen, fitted or followed up, that’s a medical negligence claim, which starts with an initial notice and has its own steps. (PIPA s 9A)
Approved isn’t the same as safe
Regulator approval isn’t a defence, and a recall doesn’t prove your case on its own.
Three ways to claim
One injury. Up to three legal routes.
Product claims are usually made in more than one way at once, because each has different rules. You’re only compensated once.
-
Track 1
Safety defect
Against the manufacturer
No need to prove carelessness. You must prove a safety defect, and that it caused the injury. (Australian Consumer Law s 138) May not be available where workers’ compensation applies. (s 146)
-
Track 2
Consumer guarantee
Against the seller or maker
Products must be of acceptable quality, which includes being safe. (s 54) Only for the buyer, or someone who got it from them, such as a gift recipient.
-
Track 3
Negligence
Against anyone careless
Against a maker, importer or supplier that was careless in design, manufacture, testing or warnings.
What makes it defective
Is it as safe as people generally are entitled to expect?
That’s the test. (Australian Consumer Law s 9) Most defects fall into one of three kinds.
Contents: kinds of defect
- DesignThe product was made as intended, but the design itself was unsafe.
- ManufactureSomething went wrong in making this one: a faulty part, batch or assembly.
- WarningsThe instructions or warnings didn’t tell you about a hazard, or how to use it safely.
What a court looks at
- How it was marketed, and what for
- Its packaging, marks, instructions and warnings
- What might reasonably be done with it
- When the maker supplied it
Approved isn’t the same as safe. Regulator approval isn’t a defence, and a recall doesn’t prove your case on its own.
What the maker can argue.
- The defect didn’t exist when the maker supplied it
- It was only there because the product had to meet a mandatory standard
- Scientific or technical knowledge when the maker supplied it couldn’t have found the defect
- For a part: the defect came only from the finished product’s design, markings, instructions or warnings
The maker has to prove a defence. (Australian Consumer Law s 142) Your own share of responsibility can also reduce damages. (Competition and Consumer Act 2010 (Cth) s 137A)
How it happens
How medical devices cause injury.
A device can be defective in its design, in how it was made, or in its instructions and warnings to surgeons. (Australian Consumer Law s 9)
Implants that fail early
Hip, knee and other joint replacements that wear, loosen or break sooner than expected.
Mesh and slings
Mesh that erodes, shrinks or causes lasting pain.
Device malfunctions
Pumps, pacemakers and monitors that fail or give wrong readings.
Warnings not passed on
Risks the maker didn’t warn surgeons or patients about.
Reactions to materials
Metal debris, inflammation or reactions to what the device is made from.
Who may be responsible
More than one business can answer for one product.
More than one may be liable. Where several are liable as manufacturer, each can be liable for the full amount. (Australian Consumer Law s 144)
The manufacturer
The company that made the device, or holds itself out as its maker. (Australian Consumer Law s 7)
Ask for: Your implant card, and the device’s name and batch
The importer
If the maker has no place of business in Australia, the business that imported the device is treated as the manufacturer. (s 7)
Ask for: The device’s entry on the TGA register (ARTG)
The hospital or surgeon
Not usually responsible for a defect in the device itself, but may be for how it was chosen, fitted or followed up. That’s a medical negligence claim, with its own steps.
Ask for: Your operation notes and follow-up letters
Straight after
Four things to do now.
- Step 1
Get your implant details
Ask the hospital for your implant card, operation notes and the device’s name and batch.
- Step 2
Keep recall letters
Keep any letter or email about a recall, product alert or review of your device.
- Step 3
Ask for the device
If it’s removed, ask the hospital in writing to keep it, and not to send it back to the maker.
- Step 4
Check the TGA
Search the TGA’s recalls and alerts for your device, and save what you find. A recall is evidence, not proof.
Compensation
What you can claim.
Claims are usually made under more than one track, because the damages rules differ. Medicare and Centrelink may need to be repaid from a settlement.
- Pain and sufferingAssessed under the rules for the claim that succeeds. Consumer law injury claims can have their own thresholds.
- Past and future lost earningsWages and super you’ve lost, and what the injury will cost you in future.
- Treatment costsMedical, hospital and rehabilitation costs, past and future.
- Care from familyIf it’s needed for at least 6 hours a week for at least 6 months.
- Paid care and aidsHelp at home, equipment and changes you need because of the injury.
- Damage to your thingsOther personal property or your home damaged by the defect. (Australian Consumer Law ss 140, 141)
How a claim runs
From the first call to court, if it’s needed.
No-obligation first consultation
We look at the product, what happened, who may be responsible and your time limits.
Secure the product
Kept safe, with a record of who has held it. Any testing is independent.
Notice of claim
A notice of claim goes to each business you claim against, within the time limit. (PIPA s 9, or the CTP or medical negligence rules where they apply)
Experts and evidence
Engineering or medical experts on the defect and what it caused.
Conference and offers
A compulsory conference, then written final offers if it doesn’t settle. (PIPA ss 36, 39)
Court, if needed
If the claim hasn’t resolved, proceedings start within the time limit.
Costs
What it costs you.
No win, no fee*
You don’t pay our professional fees if your claim is unsuccessful.
If your claim succeeds, outlays are repaid from your settlement at cost. If your claim does not succeed, we absorb those outlays unless you have agreed to pay them under your client agreement.
If court proceedings start, you may have to contribute to the other party’s costs. Your written client agreement sets out any protection we provide.
We explain this in writing before you sign, and again in detail before any proceedings are commenced.
Fully transparent charges
Our fees
Our professional fees are calculated according to an agreed scale that sets out the charge for each type of work performed — not as a percentage of your settlement.
Out-of-pocket case expenses such as court filing fees, barrister fees and expert reports are charged at cost, with no loading.
Our fee structure is transparent and clearly specified in your written client agreement.
Uplift or success fee
In some cases, an uplift or success fee applies to reflect the risk we take in conducting your claim on a no win, no fee* basis. Any uplift fee is explained and set out in your written client agreement before you sign.
No-obligation first consultation
You decide whether to go ahead once you know your options and the likely costs.
Everything in writing
Fees and outlays are set out in a client agreement before we start.
Questions
Questions people ask.
Approval doesn’t stop a claim. A device can be on the TGA register and still not be as safe as people generally are entitled to expect. (Australian Consumer Law ss 9, 142)
No. A recall can support a claim, but you still need to show your device had the defect and that it caused your injury.
Usually the maker, for a defect in the device. If the problem was how the device was chosen, fitted or followed up, a medical negligence claim against the surgeon or hospital may also be possible. The two have different notices and time limits.
Several clocks run at once. A notice of claim is generally due within 9 months of the injury (or of first symptoms, if later), or 1 month after you first ask a lawyer to act for you and the respondent is identified, whichever comes first. (PIPA s 9) A safety defect claim must start within 3 years of when you knew, or should have known, of the loss, the defect and the maker, and no later than 10 years after the maker supplied the device, which can be before your surgery. (Australian Consumer Law s 143) For injury damages, another limit can start earlier. A negligence claim has its own limit.
Ask the hospital in writing to keep it, and not to return it to the maker. It may be the most important evidence in your claim.
Hurt by another kind of product?
Keep the records
Hurt by a medical device?
Your first consultation covers who may be responsible and which time limits apply. There’s no obligation to go ahead.
No win, no fee*: You don’t pay our professional fees if your claim is unsuccessful. If your claim succeeds, outlays are repaid from your settlement at cost. If your claim does not succeed, we absorb those outlays unless you have agreed to pay them under your client agreement. If court proceedings start, you may have to contribute to the other party’s costs. Your written client agreement sets out any protection we provide. We explain this in writing before you sign, and again in detail before any proceedings are commenced. This page is general information, not legal advice about your situation.